Carlisle Inn
  • ★★★
  • Hotel
  • Sugarcreek
  • 9.6/10

Carlisle Inn

Featuring an indoor swimming pool with a retractable roof, Carlisle Inn is located in Sugarcreek, Ohio. The property serves complimentary daily breakfast. Guests can find an Amish-style restaurant adjacent to the inn. Each simply furnished room is equipped with air conditioning. All rooms include a flat-screen TV. Select rooms will feature a balcony or patio. Room service is available. Guests at the Sugarcreek Carlisle Inn can enjoy live performances at the on-site theatre. There is also a fitness centre, a gift store and children’s playground. Free WiFi access is available. Dutch Valley Restaurant is located on the property and serves authentic Amish Dishes. The on-site Dutch Valley Market sells local meats, cheeses and foods. Carlisle Inn is 3.4 km from Alpine Hills Museum and 11.9 km from Warther Museum.

  • Top location: Highly rated by recent guests (9.8)
  • Breakfast info: Continental, Buffet
  • Free parking available at the hotel
  • Loyal customers: There are more repeat guests here than most other properties.

Kids

Children of any age are welcome.

Dogs

Pets are not allowed.

Address

1357 Old Route 39, Sugarcreek, OH 44681, United States, Sugarcreek, United States

Facilities

Indoor swimming pool Non-smoking rooms Fitness centre Restaurant Facilities for disabled guests Free WiFi Free parking Breakfast

Gallery

a large bedroom with a bed and a couch at Carlisle Inn in Sugarcreek
a row of chairs in a room with a podium at Carlisle Inn in Sugarcreek
a bedroom with two beds and a desk and a television at Carlisle Inn in Sugarcreek
a porch of a house with a lamp post and flowers at Carlisle Inn in Sugarcreek
a pharmacy aisle with shelves of products in a store at Carlisle Inn in Sugarcreek
a gym with exercise bikes and a person in the background at Carlisle Inn in Sugarcreek
a living room with a bed and a couch at Carlisle Inn in Sugarcreek
a bedroom with a bed and a living room at Carlisle Inn in Sugarcreek
a bunch of flowers in front of a building at Carlisle Inn in Sugarcreek

Reviews

Weyrick 10/10
United States 🇺🇸

Beautiful Inn with plenty to do on site.

Pros: Outstanding Continental breakfast with exceptional coffee. We enjoyed our King Suite which included a fireplace and jetted tub. With the Bakery, Restaurant, Market, gift shop & theater you could easily not leave the premise.

Cons: Our trip was a tad early so not all of the Christmas display was put up yet. What had been done was beautiful.

Leonard 10/10
United States 🇺🇸

Relaxing stay for spring break

Pros: We thought the beds were comfortable and it was nice to sit on the balcony and when you laid in bed you could see the outside through the balcony door. We enjoyed the 24 hours hot chocolate and coffee and the pool was opened early in the morning and it closed late at night. Like the close line in the shower that I've only seen at waterpark for drying wet clothes Restaurant within walking distance and playground in front yard

Cons: Didn't realize there was a microwave on the 2nd floor for left overs until later b/c there is none in the room. Didn't realize there was a laundry facilty b/c it's hidden behind a solid door but that's my fault for not asking.

Steven 10/10
United States 🇺🇸

Pros: This is our third stay at the Carlisle Inn for a Pastor/Spouse Retreat. The inn meets all of my expectations. We are planning on visiting again .

Carol 10/10
United States 🇺🇸

Pros: Everything was great! Food was good. Pool hours were very good.

Steven 10/10
United States 🇺🇸

Pros: The king deluxe room was perfect for our anniversary getaway, very clean facility, and the staff was great.

Lisa 10/10
United States 🇺🇸

Wonderful

Pros: The breakfast is great. The staff was very nice. Rooms were spacious and clean. The common areas were large, so it never felt too crowded.

Nagui 9/10
United States 🇺🇸

Nice but not for relaxation because of all the noise I’d rather go the the Carlisle at Walnut Creek

Pros: Breakfast area was clean considering the huge number of kids with their parents. Breakfast items that were supposed to be hot, was hot. Great breakfast. The room was clean, we opted to not clean the room for the 2nights we were there. We had to leave short one night for medical reasons. One remark my wife had that the toilet was low for her and we had to ask for a raised toilet seat for a handicap and luckily they had it.

Cons: None

Robert 8/10
United States 🇺🇸

Pros: Beautiful decor. Property gift shop. Restaurant. Clean. breakfast included

Cons: Stayed 2 nights in executive king suite. Bed not comfortable. Coffee in breakfast area not good, just institutional coffee. (Restaurant coffee very good) 1st morning free breakfast didn't have a cooked egg option. Sausage Gravy and Biscuits not for me.

Sheri 10/10
United States 🇺🇸

Incredible!

Pros: All went well! We wished the surrounding shops opened before 10:00 a.m. so we missed that experience. Also, we arrived on a Sunday and understand nothing is open on Sundays in Amish Country. However, a complimentary dinner would be nice for Sunday travelers for the evening meal. Otherwise, we were thrilled with our stay and the beautiful weather as well!

Cons: Our overnight stay was exceptional! The staff was very friendly and helpful.

Anastasia 9/10
United States 🇺🇸

We came to the Inn for couple nights to celebrate our 20th Anniversary. We really enjoyed our stay!

Pros: Very comfortable and clean room. Loved the location, and the area with the restaurant, bakery and the gift shop right next to the Inn. Great breakfast options, we also enjoyed evening snack of popcorn and cookies every night.

Nearby Hotels

Dover Inn and Suites
Dover Inn and Suites
Hotel
10.0 km
Schoenbrunn Inn
Schoenbrunn Inn
Hotel
11.8 km
Inn at Amish Door
Inn at Amish Door
Hotel
16.3 km
Berlin Heritage Inn
Berlin Heritage Inn
Hotel
16.5 km
Berlin Grande Hotel
Berlin Grande Hotel
Hotel
16.8 km

Price map of nearby hotels

More Accommodation

The Lodge at Fields of Home
The Lodge at Fields of Home
Holiday home
Millersburg

Restaurant

Dutch Valley Restaurant
Open for: Breakfast • Lunch • Dinner

Explore by destination